I would love the new title/badge, maybe aswell a higher role in discord...? but what interest me more is the world of possibilities that such addition would provide to the fansite, maybe this could help affording a bot that integrate the new post in discord (you know, for lighthearted discussions without crowding the fansite with comments)? maybe improving even more the website (im a passionate lover of dark mode, and light mode is killing my eyes ;-;), there's not limit for imagination!
In the other hand these are the points that i like the most:
-A low cost monthly rent.
-Removing completely the ads (monthly or permanently, up to you, even an "permanently after x ammount of $ is okay for me).
and maybe others like:
-a monthly share of a small ammount of points (25-50) stopping at 500-1k? (obtaining points isn't as easy for everyone)
-maybe increasing the length/cappacity of answers? (i have seen some ppl struggling with the cappacity of their amazing answers, is a shame)