+3 votes
141 views
by (49 points)

Reading several recent questions and answers, I've noticed a pattern of questions that are extremely simple and for which the answer could be very easily found in other fansites. For example:

https://www.tibiaqa.com/5532/where-can-i-get-golden-sea-horse-figurine

There is nothing special about this item that makes this question relevant, in my opinion. It's a simple quest reward, and how to obtain it can be easily found in fansites which provide guides to quests and information about items. We can list several examples:

Of course, one can argue that TibiaQA is an independent website that should have all the information on itself. But in my opinion this does not help TibiaQA grow as a unique fansite (which it is), and can instead simply become a repetition of content that already exists elsewhere. If questions like that one become common, then the possibility to start asking "how to get item X" for all the thousands of items in Tibia becomes real. The same can be done for all missions of all quests: "how do I go through the Pits of Inferno maze?" and even things as simple as item's properties: "how many imbuing slots the Rod of Destruction has?". None of this is hard to find, sometimes the own game's Cyclopedia will have the information. 

I'm not saying questions and answers must be absolutely unique in content that does not exist in other fansites. As a fansite admin myself, I can assure you that all fansites help each other, directly or indirectly. Players will of course search on Wikis to reply questions here, but wiki editors will also learn things on TibiaQA and add that to their fansites. I do believe there should be guidelines, however, for this reasons:

  • Allowing for such extremely simple questions makes way for abusing the points system. Users can start asking all sorts of simple questions like the examples I gave and even answer them themselves for the points. Yes, answering your own question is not necessarily a problem and even recommended if done honestly, but it's not always good.
  • These questions may hide questions with real value. Once someone is on TibiaQA, there's a chance they'll browse and see what else is going on. If the website looks like a bunch of things that were just copied/translated from other fansites, it won't feel like a place worth returning to. 

Since I gave an example of a question I think is bad, let me give a fresh example of a question I think is good:

https://www.tibiaqa.com/5575/set-and-items-able-to-reduce-mana-drain-damage-for-knights-level-100

Even though the answer to this question can be found in fansites as well, it's more specific because it's asking for the Knight vocation and for a level range. This means the answer has to filter the data it finds, for example. Furthermore, a good answer can go further and such cases and make notes about the item. For example, perhaps one of the existing items for this condition is extremely expensive and thus not affordable by a level 100 player, meaning a simple list of items (as you'd find on fansite lists) wouldn't be as good as an answer given to this question. 

Having said all that: should a line be drawn regarding the complexity of questions? Or does the community of TibiaQA believes that every single question is valid, even if the answer can be easily found elsewhere, such as the client's Cyclopedia. 

3 Answers

0 votes
by (77 points)
In my opinion all questions that gives new knowledge to the site are valid , since for me the finally of this fansite is to create a nice database of questions and answers that will helps a lot of people on their researchs. If we start to restrict this knowledge we will have less questions and more questions about opinion based that dont helps to the finally of this website , for non opinion based questions or discuss questions you have reddit or something like that.

This is my opinion , but at the end is not on my hand to determinate whats good and whats wrong , anyway those downvotes on my question of the golden sea horse figurine are not fair , since you can agree or not the rules of this website but is not fair to downvote a question just because you dont want this fact.
0 votes
by (208 points)

In short answer YES.

The exactly idea of the site is:

  1. Make their own database
  2. Make a different type of content about Tibia thing and not another fansite full of extensive guides.
0 votes
by (31 points)

I agree 100% in your point of view as I said in this post about the  golden sea horse.

And about answering your own questions, I agree It can be ok sometimes. But me for example, even when I asked questions which answers I already knew to increase the knowledge of the fansite, I waited for other members to answer before me, for example:

https://www.tibiaqa.com/3626/change-your-character-does-summoner-outfit-become-mage-outfit-vice-versa

And If nobody showed up with a good answer, I gave the answer myself:

https://www.tibiaqa.com/2948/after-unlocking-an-area-how-much-time-before-a-raid-are-you-notified

I know the rules, and I know what is allowed, but for me this is ethics

Welcome to Meta TibiaQA, where we post announcements and hold discussions about the TibiaQA. If you want to view or ask Tibia related questions, see the core site.
TibiaQA.com is a fansite. Please note that the only official website is Tibia.com. The game Tibia and the website Tibia.com are copyrighted by CipSoft GmbH.
...